When He Breaks Your Heart He Feels Nothing

you feel as if a piece of you is missing. But one of the signs he loves you is that while he embraces your eclectic personality, he’s also not willing to. Read He breaks his arm from the story Shawn Mendes Imagines by shawnieboyimagine with 8,105 reads. When you ask him directly how he feels about you, he's unsure. Take one day at a time. You will heal if you go into the pain. He takes no delight in the suffering of his people. In the weeks just after being dumped, the person who was dumped will likely. A month ago, I was visiting, and Lover said he doesn’t know who he is right now, and needs to focus on his own mental health and knows that it breaks my heart and breaks his too, but he needs some time for himself, for self care and therapy. for me—nothing could be farther from the truth. I hope you find your path. "I think he feels very protective of you. 10 ZX9629A ZX9629A_460. ” You’ve been good. The feeling of hurt or being “broken hearted” seems like an inevitable part of life. If only your heart ever, craves for me or my presence… If only you feel that love again someday for me, If only you are affected someday by my absence… Only you can end all my suffering and this unbearable pain, If only you would know what you could never procure… If only you go through the memories of past once again,. Five Things You Must Do When Your Spouse Has Had An Affair (Repost) { We are reposting this series of posts today and tomorrow as a resource for you to pass on to those you know who are in this situation. As for the intentions, it seems to me you would already been given the signs of how he "really" feels about you. He won’t necessarily admit it, but your man needs your complete loyalty. There's no question that heart palpitations at menopause are related to changing hormones. Just Jesus. He could have been mightily used by God. He offers the same grace to you, and invites you to come to him. A man’s deepest fear is that he is not good enough. If you can get your man to understand that marrying you doesn’t mean he has to change himself for you or letting go of the thing he loves – He will come around and be ecstatic about creating a life with you. Trust that He is working for your good, even when you do not understand. It will heal, even if you don't believe it now. In every moment, we have God With Us. Well, you have to maneuver yourself in a position to where you feel you can get your emotional hooks into him. What do you do if your boyfriend of over 3 years breaks up with you because he feels distant from you when you're away at college but tells you when you come home things MIGHT work out?. All of your friends hate him now, don. How to heal a broken heart. He said he wasn’t ready to let his family go and that he was sorry. What are you supposed to do when you feel like God is the One who allowed your broken heart? It is your heart’s desire. He had a heart of gold from the inside out. Babys upset. A damned defeat was made. I know its frustrating and i accept that i too am. He punctuates his conversation equally with Persian couplets and Vedic. And then he gave examples of different “events,” which can cause a spouse to close a protective finger over their heart. it means he regrets something if anything at all. When you are attempting to rekindle your wife's love, use this time to develop and strengthen your relationship with God. May my son walk after You, God, and fear You and keep Your commandments and obey Your voice. Let him know its about loving each other, not measuring up to some standard. Understanding your man's position is a big part of getting him back. Well, you have to maneuver yourself in a position to where you feel you can get your emotional hooks into him. You want a suitor, not a friend! You’re right. Just because a guy flirts with you does not mean that he has strong feelings for you, what’s important is that you judge his “intention” while he flirts with you. He bought me expensive jewelry, took me on getaways, anything to charm me. I believe that the meaning is deeper than that here is the passage. So much to mention But you can't find the words. One of my favorite resources for restoring broken marriages is Marriage Today by Jimmy Evans. Don't respond to his texts if he's with her unless it's about the kids. These are the 10 thoughts that first cross. Bucky supposes that he can’t really blame Steve for not knowing how he feels or … not feeling the same way as Bucky. Now, it seems that time has come and gone. Created with Sketch. Boyfriend of 4. People and things leave so better things can come. there is another guy who i know likes me and i thought about going. Whether they even realize it or not, it is true. Which he has already with the kids. fanfiction, sick, mendesarmy. That boy who just broke your heart, don't sweat about him. It's been the talk of the chart-watching world for nearly the entire year, and it's all culminated in this: Lil Nas X's "Old Town Road" finally breaking the long-held record of 16 weeks at No. I can't even begin to know how it feels and I hope I never will. Your friends try to say "it will all get better in time" but you just want to yell at them "NO IT WONT!. Plus, even if he were brave enough to admit it, he didn’t have a. You can be sure that God will respond to your pleas for mercy. just as he is about to be yanked free; and a tail bats a prospective hero. ” If you two intend on staying together, you need to view yourselves as a team. The feeling of hurt or being “broken hearted” seems like an inevitable part of life. I am just heartbroken for you and your family. You’ve never experienced a love like this. A while back he got into it pretty hot and heavy with SEK over at Lawyers, Guns, and Money. So I went downstairs for a while to gather my thoughts. he should love me enough to just be able to imagine me right? or wrong? i know men are men and they do that. Batman breaks in and attempts to reason with Freeze, informing him that the GCPD now know of Boyle's crimes, but the latter refuses to care, as he shoves Boyle into a cryo tube, claiming that it won't matter what Nora feels about his crimes, as the accident had destroyed any chance of his feeling any emotions. You must admit a few women would be more than happy to be in your position too. Avoid friction and pressure during the healing digest. Sure, you may get the butterflies in the beginning but when love is real, it goes deeper than, as Lindsay Lohan put it in Mean Girls, “feeling like your stomach is going to fall out of your butt. When your boyfriend breaks up with you, the first thing you may want to do is to call him, tell him how you feel, and hope that he's going to want you back. Instead of breaking it off and trying to heal myself like a normal person, I would do just about anything to keep the relationship going. But if I don't monitor things carefully, I can move into full seasons where I don't feel much of anything at all. 5 Ways To Move Ahead. How to heal a broken heart. He always made sure that you had a great day. I ask that his spirit haunts you. Even if you desire to remain anonymous, we want to add your love to our collection. If prayer is an art, so is flirtation: only your true artist, to whom music is a thing serious as his own life — only he knows how to flirt with music, to follow up a Bach fugue with a café waltz and derive, as it were, equal pleasures from both. In other words, he will change our hearts so we experience Spirit-given, heart-felt worship, and once again see and feel the glory of God in Jesus Christ. Accept His offer of solitude in the midst of tumult. Apparently as he was yelling in her face he was also spitting in her face but not on purpose so she tells him not to spit on her but he kept yelling and apparently also spitting so she deliberately spit on him. Your heart is breaking because you miss that person so much and seem unable to understand why it had to end. all you can do is think about him. He wants to talk in 3 weeks to "see how he's feeling" he sssured me I was not the problem, yet said I was part of the problem. Sadness occurs when the heart is stone cold and lifeless. Allow yourself to feel it all and when you’re done give yourself permission to let it go. Imagine that your partner is your audience. -Samuel Chadwick. 3 Bulletproof Mindsets to Get Over Heartbreak. He was a wonderful man in so many ways. I told him my insecurities about myself and how I feel porn, but he looks for women that have what I would like to have been blessed with. He was a broken man with a broken heart. When your guy talks a lot about his ex and tells stories about their past, he's definitely not over her yet. ” “Never mind,” he growls as he tries to push past me. We know the man isn't naturally trusting – he's afraid of robbers. No Tienes Corazon 3. 3: 5 Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding; 6 in all your ways submit to him,and he will make your paths straight. I never had butterflies thinking about him. "I feel bad. Yet all I hear about, over and over, is the amazing, tall, cute, sexy, charismatic, funny, successful guy who breaks your heart when he doesn't want to commit to you. He didn’t have a heart attack. ” Which brings us to the last point. how does a cancer man act when in love? what are some signs he's falling for you? i take it he's not going to be open about it? or would they venture it if they were truly in love? how do you get them to initiate any sign of deep emotion without outright just pouring your emotions out? ok, show them - Originally posted in the Cancer forum. I too have wondered how much longer he can keep going. He keeps saying he doesn't know why this happened and none of what I stated above is the reasoning. eurohandball. He made you love pictures that were just sort of "blah" before. It’s scary, but the emotional trauma of marriage and divorce is harmless to your body in that it does not stop your heart, it does not break your spine, it does not clot your arteries. " These next two sent in by Rena "Yesterday brought the beginning, tomorrow brings the end, but somewhere in the middle we've become best of friends. This is especially the case if the person we're seeing breaks up with us in a text message (tacky) or calls to break up but doesn't really want to talk about it (selfish and rude). I had tried to get over him and move on many times, but I find it extremely difficult. How to Get Your Boyfriend Back When He Broke Up with You. It sounds a little obvious, but there's no sugar coating here. He calls it his default mode. I know he feels pain about that already but thats what he brang on himself, life is karma. He says: Nothing happened, really. especially now knowing he was never sad and feels most likely relieved and excited to be out of the long. He flatters you to death from day one. So much to mention But you can't find the words. i dont know why im really writing this but im in the smesituation as the 2 women i just read aobut how so you heal a heart that has been broken when your spouse tells your a year ago that he had cheated not once but 4 times my whole word came crashig sown around me and here it is a year later and it still hurts i go throughspurts of feeling insecure not only about my marriage but my slef. Only you can determine if it's worth trying, but I feel that it is still worth trying even is he/she broke up with you several times depending on why they kept breaking up with you and how long the relationship lasted each time. I raised my value and he was so frustrated. he does not know it, yet perhaps only on some weird"what is happening level" where he feels disquiet. Frankie J - I Hope He Breaks Your Heart (Official Video) therealfrankiej1. BN GOSWAMY IS India’s best known art historian, and our answer to Indiana Jones—or actually, Indiana Jones’ father, as played by Sean Connery in the movies. He punctuates his conversation equally with Persian couplets and Vedic. If only your heart ever, craves for me or my presence… If only you feel that love again someday for me, If only you are affected someday by my absence… Only you can end all my suffering and this unbearable pain, If only you would know what you could never procure… If only you go through the memories of past once again,. When doing the right thing breaks your heart and feels like shit I haven't written much since Thursday and there's a good reason for that. Editor’s Note: Kimberly shares her story on going through a breakup with the man she thought she would marry. it is so horrible to give your entire heart to someone, and then have them exit from your life and then that's it. 7 Year Old Crying, Emotional, Saying He's a Bad Kid. Its been so hard. there is another guy who i know likes me and i thought about going. I feel great. The women I’ve met endured emotional abuse for years and no one knew about it. If a guy breaks your heart he probably doesn't give a shit. You might question yourself, blame yourself, or not see the severity of the situation. High blood sugar feels like failure. He said I would be hearing from him nd I can go up to va and he will come here and visit but something is missing. Unfriend, unfollow, see ya later. I am on week 5 of mine and it is so devastating. I am lonely as this is all done just for him. He wants to have both you and this other women WHEN he wants to do so. The reality is a man’s ego – self-confidence – sense of worth – is greatly tied to his wife. While that is currently still up in the air, Restrepo was actually originally told by UM he would play defense. And he’s used that idea to help humans find each other. The idea of leaving him and breaking my sons heart is killing me but I am just at my whit’s end. Douglas Allen 1,287 views. Feeling hurt, I breathe in. He always acts like nothing happened after our arguments and I always end up staying even though I tell him that we shouldn’t be together if he feels I am crazy. It is recommended to wear a hat and sunglasses to shield your facial skin, the most delicate and vulnerable to permanent damage Skin Care Routine. At first it was he would do anything not to loose me but then would come I was nothing he ever wanted. No connection, no motherly love or care. He is in SO much pain it breaks my heart. He knows your pain and he longs to hold you and comfort you. Even though he wants me to give him another chance, I really do want to deep down, but he broke my heart once, and will probaly do it again. I feel like he's not over me. Fell in love and she got wed, Now the man that she loved, Dont you know that he walked away. Thus you will ever burn with fraternal love, both for him who is already your brother and for your enemy, that he may by loving become your brother. ~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966. Men and women don't see text messages in quite the same light post break up. Enter HOTSPUR, WORCESTER, MORTIMER, and GLENDOWER MORTIMER These promises are fair, the parties sure, And our induction full of prosperous hope. You will ignore the heart being optimistic things will be different but what you might not know, your heart is 'bleeding' because of the continuous heart resulting from frequent breakup. If you look inside, you may discover that underneath hurt feelings is a deeper hurt - the kind of hurt that feels shattering, the kind of hurt that hurts the heart. So, even though I did not physically travel to Guatemala, it feels like my heart did. Tell that voice to go away and allow yourself to feel your pain. If you're worried about your relationship, read Men Who Can't Love: How to Recognize a Commitmentphobic Man Before He Breaks Your Heart. "He is a dick who gets a hard on from makin' me miserable, don't confuse him 'fightin' to defend me' as anythin' other that a nasty pit bull protectin' its favourite chew toy. He encouraged anyone who feels the symptoms of a ministroke or a heart attack to go get checked out immediately. ” All miracles begin by giving what you HAVE to. He was a jerk, he treated me badly, we broke up, I moved on, and that was that. How Palpitations Work. His bride turns her back on Him continually and run towards that, which causes Him to feel betrayed. He even gave up his video game all-nighters to cuddle with you and watch romantic comedies. He wonders about his competition. It’s a fine line this guy has to walk between letting you be yourself and not letting you fall. I ask that his spirit haunts you. It is terrifying to lose someone. But what to do when he doesn't call?. It exposes a simple, horrible truth about men and shows you how to find out the real truth about how he feels about you, what he wants from you, and how to make a man truly yours forever. She tells him the horrible things she has done have come back to haunt her. He learned to prefer getting his feelings hurt rather than experience the existential life feeling of feeling shattered. I most definitely didn't want to keep feeling this way, alone in a love affair meant for two. You become a weary person, trying to please your husband’s unreasonable demands but rarely is he pleased. But the way he goes still, blinks and settles into it; look how much he wants this kind of gentle kindness and seriously, this man breaks my heart over and over again. When a girl breaks your heart It can really suck when a girl breaks your heart. Ewell's daughter in To Kill a Mockingbird?' and find homework help for other To Kill a Mockingbird questions at eNotes. He still wants to be with me but is in a new city and also wants to date around. Reilly Really Feels Emotional About Ralph’s Arc In Ralph Breaks The Internet Updates Reilly told us why he was But the core of the duo's friendship is very much. Making 3 and 4 knots in the wrong direction, but the other tack would take us back toward land, and I want to get away from it and the shipping. Gene tells Finny that he is sorry and then leaves. Follow up with any missing information they may need to not do it again. He is not being snotty or a show-off, he is really just very excited to be learning about a subject he feels strongly about. Before you can take steps toward reversing your break up, you'll first need to know exactly how your ex boyfriend currently feels about you. I must do this when he does not know. he turned around & looked right at me and said nothing. This video might break your heart or make you MAD at first But it could change your life and your relationship wit men forever!. Choose your role. We are still very young, and we don't know whats, what. No Tienes Corazon 3. He takes me shopping and give me money that he claims he only does for me,I supposed…. Your relationship seems to plateau at a certain point and stop growing. I’m believing in the resurrection and redemption of all things…even on the dark Fridays of our lives. it feels like they've ripped your heart out and jumped on it repeatedly. Signs Ex Boyfriend Still Loves You – What To Look Out For. I learned from you* *As I stared into your eyes, you asked me why I was about to cry, its because I knew you were going to say good-bye. One day everything is fine, the next it feels like your boyfriend is trying to create some distance between the two of you. He takes his phone to the bathroom. When you look at them and your heart – it’s like your heart takes all the pain and all the love for them that you have. Beth didn’t care. 5 Reasons Men Break Up With Women They Love. I'm not talking about, "how has your day been?" I'm referring to questions about your life goals, what you do on the weekends, and even if you see yourself having a big family or a small family. He wants to talk in 3 weeks to "see how he's feeling" he sssured me I was not the problem, yet said I was part of the problem. He said he felt daggers going through his heart, and he would do anything to keep me. Jerry Butler - "He Will Break Your Heart" (aka "He Don't Love You (Like I Love You)") (1960) - Duration: 2:52. You can't help but cry and be angry at the world. I have tried responding in a variety of ways. After all, this. I didn’t know if I should act on the feels of love for you, he says, and I chose wrong. This will prevent further pain and also allow your skin to breathe and react naturally into the burn. Protecting yourself and your heart is crucial for your mental and physical well-being. “Nothing Breaks Like a Heart,” Mark Ronson & Miley Cyrus Sounds like: An emotionally fragile pop banger Perfect for: Crying on the dance floor She’s a little bit country, he’s a little bit. It seems that when your significant other breaks up with you, or insults you, you will automatically feel hurt or a "broken heart". ” ~ Andrew Harvey. If you're worried about your relationship, read Men Who Can't Love: How to Recognize a Commitmentphobic Man Before He Breaks Your Heart. If only your heart ever, craves for me or my presence… If only you feel that love again someday for me, If only you are affected someday by my absence… Only you can end all my suffering and this unbearable pain, If only you would know what you could never procure… If only you go through the memories of past once again,. Want the man who broke up with you to feel the burn? What are the best ways to do this? Then he left you and broke your heart and now he's moved on like you never existed. I think a lot of people believe you have to be special to be a missionary, but I'm living proof you just have to be a person who is open to whatever God has planned for your life. Douglas has a Westboro Baptist schtick going. Weinstein added he has resigned all his charity work: “I have resigned from my work with Robin Hood, amfAR, the only thing I plan to continue with is the scholarships for women directors at USC. Proverbs 3: 5, 6 tells us to “trust in the Lord with your whole heart and lean not on your own understanding. He comforts you in the waiting. You can either choose to go through this experience or you can grow through it. When your heart is broken, your mind wants you to remember the pain. He is not ignoring you and his heart breaks over your suffering. He will just go on and text me like nothing like were together again. ~Catherine Drinker Bowen (1897–1973), Friends and Fiddlers, 1939. I have done everything possible to get them to do something, and nothing is happening. 22 ? Express your answer to two significant figures and include the appropriate units. It came to a point that I feel that he has chosen soccer betting over this relationship. However, my experience has been that in many midlife women, heart palpitations are primarily from increasing heart energy trying to get in and be embodied in a woman's life. It can be hard to get over being lied to, especially when it's your boyfriend who did the lying. God understands your pain and will comfort you as you look to Him. This is the same God who makes a diagnosis of our own civilization, and your heart. I want to explain a little more systematically the reasons why this is important. When the World Breaks Your Heart. 1 on the US adult contemporary chart for one week in 1975. He is the executive director of Heart to Heart Counseling Center in Colorado Springs, Colorado, and the author of several books including, his newest title Partner Betrayal Trauma. “Dear Evan Hansen” is a Broadway musical, so there are songs sprinkled in throughout the show. Even on a day to day level, he says nothing gets to him anymore as he has had to build a thick skin, because he doesn't talk to his immediate family. -you don't know what love is, Jessica Simpson-. Fadi Fawaz admits he feels ‘wonderful’ now the ‘truth is out’ about George Michael's death GEORGE MICHAEL’S boyfriend Fadi Fawaz has admitted he can now “grieve” after the singer’s. He hurt me so badly and if ever we so see eachother i would be honest and tell him that he was very cruel to me. all this is because I am coming from an abuse relationship, I was transform there, good girl gone. The house church, a biblical search for the real church. You must admit a few women would be more than happy to be in your position too. This is Anar Parikh, and I’m thrilled to bring you this episode, “When Fieldwork Breaks Your Heart,” guest produced by Aisha Sultan, a PhD candidate at the University of Adelaide, Australia. Funny, he knows nothing about. Nothing compares to the pain of heartbreak, and depending on his zodiac sign, here's how he will break up with you and hurt your heart. Don't contact this guy, don't respond, tell him it's over and you're moving on. You can be sure that God will respond to your pleas for mercy. UCLA's Chip Kelly Breaks Down The Bruins. God understands your pain and will comfort you as you look to Him. He is a drug addict which means, he is a master manipulator and knows how to con the strings of your heart, so that your always in his back pocket to provide help for him. but then you realize what's important in life. It's your best friend; panic enters your whole body as you rip the charger out of your cell and answer. com/career-topics/washington-d-c-maternity-and-paternity-leave Syda Productions/AdobeStock. On the contrary, there is an unbelievable amount of vitality in a broken heart. "I was so afraid Taehyung-ah, dont scare me like that"+. When he says you deserve better, he speaks the truth and it has nothing to do with if YOU think he is good enough for you and everything to do with he just knows he is not because he doesn't feel motivated to step up and be THAT man for you. He takes no delight in the suffering of his people. Reilly Really Feels Emotional About Ralph’s Arc In Ralph Breaks The Internet Updates Reilly told us why he was But the core of the duo's friendship is very much. You don’t know what love is till it breaks your heart. Jasper looks more like a vicious vampire right now than he did when we were in the Southern wars. I'd shed a lot of tears over [him], lost a lot of sleep, eaten a lot of cake batter. " Tom said he dreaded those visits, but felt helpless to stop them. Give him time to process the situation and his feelings, then you can approach him. ” I asked him if his girlfriend knew we were talking like this. Well 2 days into the trip, he tells me he wants an open relationship. Search for content, post, videos. Pray precious for God to show you because ONLY GOD KNOWS THE HEART OF US ALL. If he broke up with you, respect his decision and give him some time to see things more clearly. They would have made you feel special, important, loved!. If he's in love with you but you're fighting all the time and he's feeling miserable in the relationship, there's a good chance that he loves you but he won't stay through the misery. need you to put your. Things progress and you feel so in love, you’re jumping for joy and it truly feels like he/she must be the one, your one true Twin Flame. com (mine was a trailer) Put it on a USB drive Install the VLC app on XBOX ONE X Open VLC app and plug in your USB drive Copy the. Listen to your heart Take a listen When he's calling for you Listen to your heart Take a listen There's nothing else you. He takes me shopping and give me money that he claims he only does for me,I supposed…. Only believe, only believe. I am so sorry that your partner is treating you in such a violent and harmful manner. Its been so hard. there is another guy who i know likes me and i thought about going. Up to my thirteenth year I lived in the. com I have had a few emails come in asking how to deal with betrayal and sudden break-ups. Feeling frustration and anger, I breathe in. He will attempt to provoke behavior upon which claims of harassment can be based. Miss McKesson chewed on her lip. He won’t necessarily admit it, but your man needs your complete loyalty. Take one day at a time. And then he gave examples of different “events,” which can cause a spouse to close a protective finger over their heart. Headline When the local feels universal for poet Bernard O'Donoghue. WHEN HE BREAKS YOUR HEART he feels nothing. Dean Christian blog and commentary on Crosswalk. But everyone, everyone goes through it. He had a wounded heart, it took the rest of him. Psalm 37:4. He always acts like nothing happened after our arguments and I always end up staying even though I tell him that we shouldn’t be together if he feels I am crazy. God says “no. And then he smiled and signed the book without saying anything. When we come to Jesus, our heart-hungers will be satisfied (John 6:35). I have done everything possible to get them to do something, and nothing is happening. Bravehearted Beauties, if you you feel stuck in your own version of Good Friday, take heart! Your Easter is coming. When you feel the need to make your ex regret leaving you, it's important that you communicate this to him through various means. He breaks up with you and you feel completely awful - until he contacts you and says he's been "thinking" about things and wants to talk. Emotional abuse is more deceitful than physical abuse. It’s safe, and I’m elated to say, it’s super comfortable. If you suffer from any signs your heart is breaking, try to focus on how to heal a breaking heart and, with time, soon you'll start to feel better—I promise!. First things first: Chris Niosi breaks NDA on every project he gets close to. Well 2 days into the trip, he tells me he wants an open relationship. And getting into a boat he crossed over and came to his own city. to your heart if it says your in love then your love you cannot help what. "I was so afraid Taehyung-ah, dont scare me like that"+. Miley Cyrus "Nothing Breaks Like a Heart" Sure, you love Miley's party songs but she can really break your heart as well. It feels personal… Bustle. Alex Rodriguez Comforts Jennifer Lopez as She Breaks Down During Tour: 'You Don't See How Great You Are' "It was the best show I've seen so far," he lovingly tells her and the dancers, as he. When you end a relationship, you're often left feeling heartbroken. I know how you feel. This is your opportunity to have Mark answer your questions. You owe him nothing. as iv said in my last posts i. We are still very young, and we don't know whats, what. Well, guess what? That guy SUCKS! Your husband DOESN’T leave you. It can be hard to get over being lied to, especially when it's your boyfriend who did the lying. The fact-checkers, whose work is more and more important for those who prefer facts over lies, police the line between fact and falsehood on a day-to-day basis, and do a great job. Today, my small contribution is to pass along a very good overview that reflects on one of Trump’s favorite overarching falsehoods. Namely: Trump describes an America in which everything was going down the tubes under  Obama, which is why we needed Trump to make America great again. And he claims that this project has come to fruition, with America setting records for prosperity under his leadership and guidance. “Obama bad; Trump good” is pretty much his analysis in all areas and measurement of U.S. activity, especially economically. Even if this were true, it would reflect poorly on Trump’s character, but it has the added problem of being false, a big lie made up of many small ones. Personally, I don’t assume that all economic measurements directly reflect the leadership of whoever occupies the Oval Office, nor am I smart enough to figure out what causes what in the economy. But the idea that presidents get the credit or the blame for the economy during their tenure is a political fact of life. Trump, in his adorable, immodest mendacity, not only claims credit for everything good that happens in the economy, but tells people, literally and specifically, that they have to vote for him even if they hate him, because without his guidance, their 401(k) accounts “will go down the tubes.” That would be offensive even if it were true, but it is utterly false. The stock market has been on a 10-year run of steady gains that began in 2009, the year Barack Obama was inaugurated. But why would anyone care about that? It’s only an unarguable, stubborn fact. Still, speaking of facts, there are so many measurements and indicators of how the economy is doing, that those not committed to an honest investigation can find evidence for whatever they want to believe. Trump and his most committed followers want to believe that everything was terrible under Barack Obama and great under Trump. That’s baloney. Anyone who believes that believes something false. And a series of charts and graphs published Monday in the Washington Post and explained by Economics Correspondent Heather Long provides the data that tells the tale. The details are complicated. Click through to the link above and you’ll learn much. But the overview is pretty simply this: The U.S. economy had a major meltdown in the last year of the George W. Bush presidency. Again, I’m not smart enough to know how much of this was Bush’s “fault.” But he had been in office for six years when the trouble started. So, if it’s ever reasonable to hold a president accountable for the performance of the economy, the timeline is bad for Bush. GDP growth went negative. Job growth fell sharply and then went negative. Median household income shrank. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped by more than 5,000 points! U.S. manufacturing output plunged, as did average home values, as did average hourly wages, as did measures of consumer confidence and most other indicators of economic health. (Backup for that is contained in the Post piece I linked to above.) Barack Obama inherited that mess of falling numbers, which continued during his first year in office, 2009, as he put in place policies designed to turn it around. By 2010, Obama’s second year, pretty much all of the negative numbers had turned positive. By the time Obama was up for reelection in 2012, all of them were headed in the right direction, which is certainly among the reasons voters gave him a second term by a solid (not landslide) margin. Basically, all of those good numbers continued throughout the second Obama term. The U.S. GDP, probably the single best measure of how the economy is doing, grew by 2.9 percent in 2015, which was Obama’s seventh year in office and was the best GDP growth number since before the crash of the late Bush years. GDP growth slowed to 1.6 percent in 2016, which may have been among the indicators that supported Trump’s campaign-year argument that everything was going to hell and only he could fix it. During the first year of Trump, GDP growth grew to 2.4 percent, which is decent but not great and anyway, a reasonable person would acknowledge that — to the degree that economic performance is to the credit or blame of the president — the performance in the first year of a new president is a mixture of the old and new policies. In Trump’s second year, 2018, the GDP grew 2.9 percent, equaling Obama’s best year, and so far in 2019, the growth rate has fallen to 2.1 percent, a mediocre number and a decline for which Trump presumably accepts no responsibility and blames either Nancy Pelosi, Ilhan Omar or, if he can swing it, Barack Obama. I suppose it’s natural for a president to want to take credit for everything good that happens on his (or someday her) watch, but not the blame for anything bad. Trump is more blatant about this than most. If we judge by his bad but remarkably steady approval ratings (today, according to the average maintained by 538.com, it’s 41.9 approval/ 53.7 disapproval) the pretty-good economy is not winning him new supporters, nor is his constant exaggeration of his accomplishments costing him many old ones). I already offered it above, but the full Washington Post workup of these numbers, and commentary/explanation by economics correspondent Heather Long, are here. On a related matter, if you care about what used to be called fiscal conservatism, which is the belief that federal debt and deficit matter, here’s a New York Times analysis, based on Congressional Budget Office data, suggesting that the annual budget deficit (that’s the amount the government borrows every year reflecting that amount by which federal spending exceeds revenues) which fell steadily during the Obama years, from a peak of $1.4 trillion at the beginning of the Obama administration, to $585 billion in 2016 (Obama’s last year in office), will be back up to $960 billion this fiscal year, and back over $1 trillion in 2020. (Here’s the New York Times piece detailing those numbers.) Trump is currently floating various tax cuts for the rich and the poor that will presumably worsen those projections, if passed. As the Times piece reported: